User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Max Blankfeld's avatar

Claire, with all due respect, you raised a new point but did not answer my two points

Expand full comment
Claire Potter's avatar

Yes: I dispute them. There are real reasons why the guy was about to be fired. He is a liar, and without scholarly accomplishments. His account of this is a lie too.

Expand full comment
Claire Potter's avatar

And it leads me to ask again: why does Bari not fact-check these things?

Expand full comment
Max Blankfeld's avatar

I will not answer for Bari, but IтАЩll say that unfortunately we live at a time when assertions like the ones you mentioned above can also be questioned. The fact-checking should also verify if Mr. McLellanтАЩs remarks are not prompted by his own ideology. ThereтАЩs a lot of it these days.

The bottom line is that Mr. Boghossian is denouncing a reality that is very worrisome.

Expand full comment
Claire Potter's avatar

So go ahead--fact check my assertions. You could start with Boghassian's Wikipedia page, from which basic facts-like how long he worked for PSU and what he has published--are drawn from. You could click on the link--to a source more to the right than Bari. But none of that relieves Bari of her responsibility to fact check authors just because they support a point of view she is marketing.

Expand full comment
Max Blankfeld's avatar

There you go. Your last comment just exposed you.

Expand full comment
Claire Potter's avatar

Because? What did it expose me as--someone who looks for second sources and fact checks?

Expand full comment