Comments
326
User's avatar
Joe Bruno's avatar

Who says there's no good news! That you for the article.

Expand full comment
John Stewart's avatar

Apparently, there is hope. Great article.

Expand full comment
Erin Youngberg's avatar

We put our 2 kids in a Classical School right at kindergarten because we loved the idea of them focusing on developing the CHARACTER of our kids. Not teaching them what to think but how. These discussion-led classrooms are amazing, the confidence and public speaking skills are truly off-the-charts amazing to watch in these kids. I wish I'd had such an opportunity in my schooling in the 90's.

Expand full comment
Pete Howard's avatar

Thank you for this bit of great news. Green shoots. It gives me hope. This kind of education, where you are challenged by great teachers to read, argue, speak, and think critically, is exactly what America needs today. I hope this catches fire, and school choice is the vehicle to make that happen.

Expand full comment
Alan Weisz's avatar

Well done, Julia. Interestingly to me, from reading comments and the proper editing by such, you are “preaching to the choir” here. I will wager that most children in school today would not be able to form an opinion and coherently be able or have the desire to share it here.

Expand full comment
Doug Hornig's avatar

Julia - Good piece but improper use of the word 'morphed.' You probably wanted 'proliferated.' Get on your copy editor....

Expand full comment
Alice Mayer's avatar

I haven't read all the comments but suggest Julia also look at Montessori and Higher Ground Education schools and what they may be doing.

Expand full comment
Jane Spring's avatar

Parents must do the best they can to educate their children to think, read and write in that order. Vouchers is an issue in Texas elections where I live. Tax money could be used for each child with parent’s discretion. Oh, I forgot…government knows best.

Thank you for this well-written article!

Expand full comment
Charlie B's avatar

If we can keep this movement going it will teach more young people how to read, write, think, speak and debate. These new tools might give students confidence that they can grow and function and advance in the world. It may provide hope.

Expand full comment
Faith Ham's avatar

My daughter is in her 10th year teaching at Atlanta Classical. Go, ACA! I’m a huge fan of classical charters, but here’s the rub. They’re still public schools, which is why they’re “free.” They are subject to the whims of legislators and bureaucrats. Applications can be denied and charters revoked in one election cycle. The way around this pitfall is PRIVATE classical schools with obscenely rich endowments that can generously underwrite tuitions for low-income students. So all you Ivy alums looking to redirect your donations, how about banding together to launch and endow schools that truly educate their students, starting in kindergarten.

Expand full comment
richard's avatar

Amazing that the teachers unions which have incredible power, are trying to staunch this incredibly positive form of teaching......care only about themselves, don't give a damn about society.....oh...makes sense, they're Dems!

Expand full comment
Papa Bob's avatar

Amazing and hopeful article that seems to show the pendulum is swinging back more toward the center -- but is it too little too late?

Expand full comment
Patricia J.'s avatar

This is just wonderful news! I have read several historians who believe the empires rise/empires fall trajectory is unavoidable. But I have hoped that our tradition of self-reliance and equality and individual rights might interrupt that trajectory. Looks like the restoration is starting.

Expand full comment
Michael Kupperburg's avatar

When people find out that the so called new and improved versions don't work well they have a tendency to go back to what did. It just takes longer now, with social media and influencers, etc. etc. and so forth, for people to make the decision to improve their child's life by rejecting the mandatory and imposed version.

Expand full comment
Andrew Franks's avatar

I sent my kids to a classical charter school from 2000-2010, then I sent them to local state universities. Little did I know how it would change them. They came home speaking a new language. Now trying to move them back to their classical roots. No small task.

Expand full comment
Patrick’s substack's avatar

I was a liberal arts major in the 1980’s when it was falling out of favor for the more practical studies finance, accounting and computer science. I find it interesting there is an entire industry of self help and personal betterment books out there based on the classics. They just don’t measure up to the classics.

I recognize STEM is vitally important. I just think there is a balance needs to be had. Colleges turned into tech schools teaching “how to do”.

It is no wonder society has avoid of meaning and purpose and replaced w/ depression and anxiety

classic's provide a path on “ what we should do”

IE…..Vision and strategy. I am a big STEM supporter but am shocked that in the business world there are some many that lack the vision it’s nice to see that the classics are making a comeback

Expand full comment