User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Anthony's avatar

The first page of White Fragility said "whiteness doesn't exist, but denying its existence makes it more powerful" and that's when I put the book down and said "I can't."

Expand full comment
Elliot's avatar

It really says that? Wtf...

Expand full comment
Rich Smith's avatar

What really got me in the book was when she started talking about people who were “white passing”. According to her, it doesn’t matter what your ethnicity is, but only what your skin color is. That sounds like bigotry, but I guess I haven’t “done the work” enough to understand it. I had a former coworker who got super woke, and she started posting all this anti-racist stuff on Facebook, one of which said, “If you are white, you have nothing to say about racism.” What I started wondering is if that is a continuum, or is it a hard cutoff? Like, do people with darker brown skin have more privilege than people with lighter brown skin? Are they allowed to say more about racism? Or, is there some shade of beige that if your skin is lighter than that, you have white privilege? What if you are mixed race and your skin color is ambiguous? Is there a Home-Depot-style color chart that tells you when you are allowed to have an opinion on race? The whole idea seems ridiculous to me.

Expand full comment
Kara Stanhope's avatar

Yes, they call it “colorism” ...

Expand full comment
Corey Smith's avatar

It is ludicrous.

Expand full comment
Celia M Paddock's avatar

It's the brown paper bag test, readopted by the Left. Interesting how Progressive's racism looks so much like Democrats' historical racism.

Expand full comment
Anthony's avatar

Not just ridiculous but absolutely racist and evil to the core.

Expand full comment
Skinny's avatar

I can’t Anthony I couldn’t even pick the book up!

Expand full comment
Michael Burlingame's avatar

This calls to mind Mark Twain's reported quip about the latest Henry James novel: "It's one of those books that once you put down you can't pick up."

Expand full comment
Bruce Miller's avatar

What you did is what all rational, sentient, sane people need to do.

Give "the back of the hand" to this progressive idiocy and dismiss it immediately as the trash it is.

Expand full comment