230 Comments

I think a bit of perspective is needed here.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zTKJus4bUxw

Expand full comment

Agreed. I think it’s pretty clear she isn’t being truthful

Expand full comment

And in the very article you include the video that debunks the woman's claim. *Facepalm* Did anyone read past the headline?

Expand full comment

I think this girl completely mischaracterized what happened to her. She was possibly poked in the eye; the guy with the flag was not “in her face” or even looking at her. It seems like she is a bit of a clout chaser.

Expand full comment

Masks make it more difficult to identify people, but not impossible.

Keep photos and videos, with sound recordings against the day when they can be used as evidence, with advances in technology, of violent crimes.

Expand full comment

And if you read the left wing rags it doesn’t count as a stabbing because they didn’t inflict enough damage. Of course no damage is ever enough for them so…

Expand full comment

This is a criminal assault with 1 perpetrator and many criminally liable aiding and abetting

Charge them and restrict Titlie VI federal dollars and punitive damages . Moneys from Qatar are feeding these riots

Expand full comment

Thank you for being so brave and being on the right side of history. These protests are like the German Bund rallies of the 1930s.

Expand full comment

Expel them. Erase their academic records. Make it as if they had never attended Columbia.

Expand full comment

Stay safe, Sahar! I hope the Yale administrators see sense!

Expand full comment

I hope you sue Yale for millions of Dollars. All of those students are burning up millions of dollars in tuition from their parents. A waste of education , a wasted argument from uneducated students.

Expand full comment

The right to protest consists of speech and assembly. When it starts to take the form of harassing students who are not part of the demonstration, especially on purely racial grounds, that's when I would bring out the high-pressure firehoses.

Expand full comment

Terrifying! Where are the lawsuits? Why are real police not allowed to protect students? Hunger strike when school is almost out?! Sure. There should be photos posted of these people who are themselves effectively terrorizing others. Where are the criminal charges? I think there is a type of facial recognition that can be successful even with partially covered faces. This is a very very dark day in the US.

Expand full comment

If only we would put violent disorderly protestors in jail. So simple.

Expand full comment

For the past week I have been getting progressively more upset, ill, angry, depressed and hopeless. I feel completely disoriented in this country and totally helpless. My husband doesn’t want to hear about it. I don’t know where to turn or how to keep doing ordinary things in the face of this travesty. My hat is off to both of the courageous young people writing essays in the FP today.

Expand full comment

When you see the racial and ethnic makeup of the "protestors" you can see the effect of 12 plus years of indoctrination by the schools, both government run and private. Not just sad but scary.

Expand full comment

I'm so sorry you and the other Jewish students are dealing with this. It is sickening and heartbreaking. What has happened to these once respected institutions?

Expand full comment